2 Comments

19th Sep 2012 at 12:19 | By

Milwaukee Journal Sentinel Turns To Biased Sources in Act 10 Decision Coverage

By Collin Roth

One of the most prolific signs of media bias is who reporters go to for quotes and “expert” analysis.

In the wake of Dane County Circuit Court Judge Juan Colas’ bombshell decision to declare Act 10 unconstitutional, the mainstream media rushed to cover the decision by asking the usual suspects from higher education to weigh in. On Saturday September 15, just a day after the decision was published, the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel turned to Marquette Law School professors Janine Geske and Paul Secunda.

Janine Geske is of course the former Justice of the Wisconsin Supreme Court who retired in 1998. Upon retiring, Geske made two donations to the campaign of the most liberal member of the Court, Chief Justice Shirley Abrahamson. This past spring, Geske along with a group of partisans and Walker recall signers, helped author an editorial in the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel lauding the conduct of Milwaukee District Attorney John Chisholm after Media Trackers uncovered 43 members of his staff signing the recall petition. The editorial writers declared of DA Chisholm’s not-so-secret John Doe investigation, “There is no evidence of partiality or bias. There is no evidence of incompetence, undue delay or improper motive.”

Just six days after Geske’s editorial declaring “no evidence of pariality or bias,” Media Trackers published a photo of a Recall Walker sign in the yard of David Budde, the Milwaukee District Attorney’s Chief Investigator in the John Doe.

In addition to Geske, the Journal Sentinel turned to Marquette Law professor Paul M. Secunda. Secunda, an expert in labor law, opined that Colas’ appeal would receive a “frosty” reception from conservatives. But what the Journal Sentinel nor Secunda tell readers is that Secunda called Act 10 “un-American” in an editorial in Madison’s Cap Times. Secunda declared collective bargaining rights to be “human rights that international law recognizes.”

And perhaps to top it all off, look no further than Paul Secunda’s personal Twitter account to reveal his bias. His picture features the Obama 2012 logo.

Discussion | 2 Comments

  1. Barlowmaker said

    Sep 20, 2012 at 10:30 AM

    Unionista activist (Shop steward, Local 51 Madison bureau) Patrick Marley writing an unprofessional and biased report?

    Say it isn’t so.

  2. Barbara Karnowski said

    Feb 16, 2013 at 7:49 AM

    Have you noticed that whenever the Milwaukee news stations mention Scott Walker they refer to him as Walker or Scott Walker, NEVER the governor or Governor Walker. Tom Barrett is ALWAYS referred to as the mayor or Mayor Barrett, I have never heard anyone refer to him as Barrett or Tom Barrett. One of the many examples of their bias.

Leave a Comment

Your reply will be added to the comment above (Below any other replies to this comment) -

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail.

* - mandatory fields